IN THE NEWS

7 Very Good Reasons a College Should Seriously Consider Making the ACT and the SAT Optional.

Dart hitting target labeled best choice

In this article, we discuss the growing test-optional reasons. We talk about why the test-optional movement has so much momentum right now. We list the advantages to a school making the decision to drop the ACT and the SAT as requirements for admissions.

Reason 1: Students hate completing the ACT and the SAT. You may think, what does what the student like have to do with anything? Any time you require something that students hate, you are putting yourself at a competitive disadvantage.

Reason 2: Many colleges need more applications just to guarantee they will reach full enrollment and there is plenty of research to indicate that a school will get more applications if they no longer require these tests. Other schools may not need more applications but they want more applications to shape their class.

Reason 3: We now have 50 years of research to indicate that a college can drop its SAT and ACT requirement and still admit students who graduate at rates similar to the graduation rate of test-score submitters. Colleges can admit students who have similar grades to test-score submitters. Bowdoin dropped the ACT and SAT requirement in 1969 and they have substantial research validating that they can use other factors in the admission file to identify appropriate applicants. Bates, Wake Forest, and others have found they can select students without test scores and admit students with similar success in college to the test-score submitters.

Reason 4: The ACT and the SAT add an inordinate amount of anxiety and stress that is not only imprudent but is also unnecessary.

Reason 5: All the research indicates that these tests are highly correlated with parental incomes. The top test prep companies often cost a fortune. A great and compelling case can be made that colleges who rely on the ACT or the SAT are “advantaging the advantaged.”

Reason 6: A school can diversity its population by bringing in a wider swath of the American population. There are a number of major studies that show that when a college drops the requirement for test scores to be submitted, it opens up lower income and underrepresented students to new colleges that they had not previously considered. Most colleges see their environments as learning laboratories, and a diverse student brings a perspective that enhances the quality of the education of everyone around them.

Reason 7: It puts more focus on character in the evaluation process. Character will correlate very closely with grit. Character traits like grit, optimism, social intelligence, likeability, work ethic, and integrity will be valued when an admission officer cannot see a student through the prism of numbers.

Recent posts

Mark Stucker Photo

Mark Stucker

Founder
mark@schoomatch4u.com

Mark Stucker has 25 years of full-time experience in college and boarding school admissions, and in college counseling. He’s worked with private day, boarding, charter, and public-school students, as well as private clients.

He is extremely passionate about finding the right college for every student and
ensuring that the college selected is affordable for the family.

Career Highlights

  • Worked at the Phillips School doing college admission, 1991
  • Director of Annual Giving, Westtown School, 2001-2002
  • Adjunct College counselor for students at the Westtown School, 2003–2009
  • Associate Director of Admissions at Westtown School, 2002–2009
  • Chair of the admissions committee at Westtown School for five years, 2004–2009
  • Traveled nationally/ internationally to recruit students at fairs, through school visits, and receptions.
  • KIPP Metro Atlanta high school and college placement counselor, 2009–2023
  • Oversaw the college counseling program for four schools by serving as the Director of College Counseling for Alumni at KIPP Metro Atlanta. Placed about 70 kids in college per year in this role from 2019-2023
  • Founded college placement educational consulting company, School Match 4U, 2010
  • Served as a Go To College NYC board member
  • Worked with over 2000 students, in all 50 states through college and boarding school admissions, high school placement, college admissions, and college placement
  • Author of the book: “171 Answers”: To The Most-Asked College Admissions Questions
  • Founder, Co-Host and Producer of the Your College-Bound Kid podcast, the most listened to college admissions podcast according to Apple in the
    “Education for Kids” Category, 2018-Present
  • Traveled to visit over 350 colleges
  • Member of IECA, SACAC and NACAC
  • Graduate of the Harvard Summer Institute for College Admissions and the Stanford Counselor outreach certificate program

 

Personal Life: Married for 35 years, Anitra and I are parents of two, our oldest is a Davidson College grad who owns a Spanish and Math tutoring company, and our youngest daughter is a graduate of the University of Georgia (BA) and North Carolina State (MA) and she is a Wellness coach at the University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill at the Kenan-Flagler Business School

Hobbies include: golf, gardening, reading, travel, watching basketball, football,
track and golf, politics, eating various ethnic cuisines

Questions about our services, our team or our availability for speaking engagements? Feel free to contact him here.

Mark Stucker (mark@schoolmatch4u.com) has 25 years of full-time experience in college and boarding school admissions, and in college counseling. He’s worked with private day, boarding, charter, and public-school students, as well as private clients. He is extremely passionate about finding the right college for every student and ensuring that the college selected is affordable for the family.

Career Highlights

  • Worked at the Phillips School doing college admission, 1991
  • Director of Annual Giving, Westtown School, 2001-2002
  • Adjunct College counselor for students at the Westtown School, 2003 – 2009
  • Associate Director of Admissions at Westtown School, 2002 – 2009
  • Chair of the admissions committee at Westtown School for five years, 2004 –
    2009
  • Traveled nationally/ internationally to recruit students at fairs, through school
    visits, and receptions.
  • KIPP Metro Atlanta high school and college placement counselor, 2009 –
    2023
  • Oversaw the college counseling program for four schools by serving as the
    Director of College Counseling for Alumni at KIPP Metro Atlanta. Placed about
    70 kids in college per year in this role from 2019-2023
  • Founded college placement educational consulting company, School Match
    4U, 2010
  • Served as a Go To College NYC board member
  • Worked with over 2000 students, in all 50 states through college and boarding
    school admissions, high school placement, college admissions, and college
    placement
  • Author of the book: “171 Answers”: To The Most-Asked College Admissions Questions
  • Founder, Co-Host and Producer of the Your College-Bound Kid podcast, the most listened to college admissions podcast according to Apple in the “Education for Kids” Category, 2018-Present
  • Traveled to visit over 350 colleges
  • Member of IECA, SACAC and NACAC
  • Graduate of the Harvard Summer Institute for College Admissions and the Stanford Counselor outreach certificate program
  • Married for 35 years, Anitra and I are parents of two, our oldest is a Davidson College grad who owns a Spanish and Math tutoring company, and our youngest daughter is a graduate of the University of Georgia (BA) and North Carolina State (MA) and she is a Wellness coach at the University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill at the Kenan-Flagler Business School
  • Hobbies include golf, gardening, reading, travel, watching basketball, football, track and golf, politics, eating various ethnic cuisines